first: this is my opinion, to not attack me for it.
lets talk about why i ranked these islands. we will be going bottom to top
the colossingum is useless. it can be for getting rid of scratch monsters (which i do) or for actual use (which, lets be honest, no one ever wants to do the colossingum daily) and even if you do, the trophies are only available there and it lowers the costume prices by 10 diamonds. pointless piece of junk.
tribal island, your one of the worst islands. first, people can leave whenever they want. completing this horrible fast-paced island is almost impossible without promoting it on a youtube channel or tiktok, which is the second problem. you kind of need it though if you want to complete plant through fire haven, because rare wubbox is there (rare wubbox is also on ethereal island, wublin, mirror plant through earth, etc.)
i am willing to complete magical sanctum, just i will go to it, breed, leave, repeat. the song sucks, especially with enchantling.
as a msm fan who has been playing since 2023, i used to like psychic island, but now its kind of repetitive (same for light island, but i will get there later) and boring. bowhead adds a lot, though.
celestial island would have been better if it wasnt as annoying. seriously, my ears hurt after hearing galvana and plixie (if thats how you spell their names, let me know) they ruin the song entirely, and super hard to complete.
seasonal shanty is what i call "the most vocal my singing monsters island." first off, for the vocals, theres jamboree, smoochle, hoola, gobbleygourd, yool, punkleton, spurrit, and monculus. too much vocals.
mirror earth island (the mirror magicals arent on this list, sorry.) is a bad island. it starts off poorly, then it throws in too many monsters. i couldnt listen to the full song because i was so annoyed.
mirror air island sucks in a way that makes it good, i know, its confusing. its very bad, but yawstrich is at a volume where it isnt cancelled out. thats what sets the bar higher than earth island mirror.
the next mirror island had so much potential, but was wasted. mirror plant island was not as great as the rest. it tried to make itself good, in which was not what came out. i dont like it. just dont.
mirror water island had a great instruments, but not a great song. they had a chance to add blabbit at the end, but he didnt sing.
me when theres a guy on wublin island who screams wake up the wublins while a drummer carries the song. wublin island is very underrated, and deserves more love. tympa carries, and same can be said with dwumroll (is that how you spell it?)
composer is under gold because it gives the ability to create songs, in which people do.. but not a lot are actually songs. most are "M I C R O W A V E" or "parents arguing." the remakes of songs like "gansters paradise" is cool. just hope theres no thick of it remake. i already know no one laughed.
gold island needs more love. its sad because it was supposed to be the last island (yet, we got amber island, magical nexus, etc.) gold island epic wubbox kind of makes the vide switch from sad to normal my singing monsters.
ethereal workshop--i mean island is not great. jellbilly goes hard, and epic jellbilly is so good. also, who ever knew rare sox existed?
ah yes, the island with the squid that says something that will get me erased from this wiki if i say, but it is a great island. its smooth with the song (which i cannot say for ethereal island) and it has great captions on youtube! like "(music)" and stuff!!!!!
first dawn of fire island, party island. its not at the bottom because its actually good? quarrister goes hard, oaktopus is good, and so is maw and shrubb! on their respective islands like plant, they dont do as good.
light island is such a good song. the beginning is rough, i know, but towards the end, it becomes so great. one day, i have yelmuts verse stuck in my head, the next tiawas. in the end, its a good song to put on repeat. (this is an edit to this when i was supposed to write about cold island, but it is repetitive, which i forgot to state. it adds to the song little by little, giving it a high ranking.)
you might be offened to find fire haven below a dawn of fire island, but i like it more. candlevara makes the song worse than the next island (spoiler: if you looked at the attachment, you would know whats next)
CAVE ISLAND IS GOOD but not fantastic. there is a line where something is good and fantastic. cave island falls in the good category. it is really obnoxious because of how much monsters are singing at the beginning of the song, which makes it difficult to listen to fully.
just face it, shugabush island is a good song (especially what its based off of) and im excited to see a whole entire singer get thier own island. its a bop too, so i recommend putting it on repeat.
SPACE ISLAND IS SUPER GOOD (IM GOING TO WRITE IN ALL CAPS FOR NO REASON) CANDLEVARA DOES NOT MAKE IT INTO THE A BAD SONG (FIRE HAVEN REFERENCE) AND CYBOP IS SOMEWHAT GOOD. THIS IS A GOOD SONG WITH A GREAT BEAT.
oh hummm oh hummm oh hummm oh hummm oh hummm oh cloud island is good.
bone island gets me grooving to the bone (get it?) but seriously, this song is very good, and stogg carries it on its back (same with withur)
cold island is fantastic (here is where i use fantastic, phenomenal, etc.) from its lyrics, to the monsters, to the colossal, to the seasonal and ethereal, it never fails to disappoint. the instrument choice is great, especially the epic wubbox. its perfect, to the icicles, to the smokey breath (reference to real life easter egg, where if you breathe out in cold weather, it turns into smoke), its just a perfect epic wubbox.
MIRROR COLD ISLAND, THANK YOU FOR BEING CREATED. if your deciding on a mirror island to complete, dont go in order, but instead start on mirror cold island. the thing that makes it great is the ethereal plays at the start, which sets the vibe, and after that, there is a cold island deedge, mammot, and dandidoo trio. it sounds like a trap remix of mammot. just please, whatever you do, start on mirror cold, and if you dont, i wont mind.
earth island isnt at the top because of one main issue: it being overrated. its a fantastic song, yes, but the hype over this becomes confusing after too many "BOSS MUSIC" videos.
now we have made it to the top ten! anyways, starting at the classic island, plant island, its catchy. its just not that great to me (since i have been typing for a long time, the lengths of the reasons will be shorter)
air island is so good, reebro is so good, yawstrich sounds beautiful, just one of the best islands overall.
amber island takes patience, but worth the wait.
fairy island is ONE OF THE BEST ISLANDS. wait did i say fairy? sorry i meant faerie.
buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, buum bum buum bum, i love fire oasis because its super grrreat (tony the tiger is ball official?!?!?!??!)
why is magical nexus so good? who made this masterpiece? i need them to come and shake my hand, because it sounds so good.
all i have to say for starhenge is rootitoot (thats how you know its a phenomenal island)
water island is so fantastic that its in the top three, more importantly, in third place. enjoy bronze!
in silver is ethereal workshop, for its intriguing story of a my singing monster island being so good! i need to shake hands with the person who created this island, water island, and starhenge.
THE GOLD METAL GOES TO A DAWN OF FIRE ISLAND, IT DESERVES THIS SPOT FOR ITS LENGTHY SONG, GOOD CHARACTERS, AND CATCHY TUNE, the continent! the mythicals have made it so much better, i cant wait for strombonin, and the gnarls and buzzinga pair is so good!
if you have made it this far and read every reason, thank you. my fingers hurt (not really) but writing this was fun. also if you didnt read all the claims.. its okay. just let me know what you think about my tier list, and i will be ranking the mythicals and mirror magical islands next!