Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-24159938-20131210231818/@comment-24577221-20140907161858

EmeraldSeashell wrote: This also repeats itself unless you do it on an island without that moknster

Eg/ toe jammer, go to Earth

Mammot, go to water

Nogginn, go to cold

Pot Belly, go to Air etc. Even there, every time you go back to one of the islands, you get the same monster that you did the first time. You can't trick the game into letting you have an infinite number of tries by jumping from one island to another, always choosing an island that's incompatible with your latest egg. Alas. :-)