Module talk:Plant Islandg/@comment-86.181.239.72-20130617151213/@comment-5832451-20130617175706

No.

Noggins have the highest rate but max out after less than 3 minutes. To truly get the highest rate, you would have to keep collecting one island, then switch to another and collect that, then keep switching. Literally, you'd be playing around the clock.

The moment a Noggin maxes out, its earning rate goes to zero and the average earning rate starts going down. Even accounting for the higher difference compared to say an Entbrat, to earn as much you'd have to be collecting for 18 hours a day and that's all day, and every day.

So unless you don't plan on getting sleep ever again, or doing nothing but playing this game constantly (and I mean constantly), then no. An island full of Noggins is NOT a great idea.

You can do similar math for the 2 and 3-element monsters. Unless you want to wake up every 30 minutes or 2-3 hrs just to play the game, it isn't worth it.