Talk:Punkleton/@comment-68.206.4.184-20121028195342/@comment-4830404-20121029135807

This may be just superstitious - I have no real proof - but I had been trying T-rox + Bowgart many, many times. I surfed through all the reported successes and they all said that they were doing Bowgart on left, and T-rox on right. I don't believe that the side you put the monster on would matter, but I figured, why not, might as well try. The second attempt that I made the switch, I got my Punkleton.

I've gone back to T-rox on left and Bowgart on right to see if I can breed a Punkleton that way, now that I have mine. It bothers me and I want to know the answer! Now, if any of you have gotten a Punkleton with that order and/or have been trying Bowgart + T-rox with no success, that would show that it was just coincidence and put my mind at ease.

But yeah, if you've been trying T-rox on left and Bowgart on right, there's no harm in randomly switching the order to see if your luck changes. I'm a bit skeptical about the ordering, and I'm more inclined to believe that the Punkleton is just rare and any "order" patterns are coincidence.