Thread:MSMMario25/@comment-24577221-20190611023057/@comment-39080707-20190611080951

BunsenH wrote: MSMMario25 wrote: Bunsen, it could be Cave Haven or something else. Why did you block me for something that will be soon be true? Because we don't know what it is, but you went ahead and created a new page that not only identified it, but added details about things like monsters. That was false information.

It's a bit like the way people think about UFOs. I believe very strongly in UFOs. There really is no question about it. There have been flying objects that couldn't be identified. Sometimes they have been identified later: weather balloons, aircraft, birds, other things. At that point, they were no longer unidentified. But the problem with UFOs comes when people "identify" them, on the basis of extremely poor evidence, to be things like alien spacecraft.

The Twitter posting teased something, but didn't give enough information to let us identify it. But you went and guessed what it might be, made up details, and created a page. Now you're throwing in another guess: Cave Haven. Or something else. We don't have wiki pages for "something, not sure what, we'll change it later if we guessed wrong".

MSMMario25 wrote: Or I could be wrong. If you have to say "Or I could be wrong" about something (apart from the fact that nothing here is absolutely certain), it doesn't belong in the main wiki space.

As for the Mimic, we have specific information that the idea was scrapped. The wiki page about it is specific on that point, and exactly why it was scrapped. It may be "obvious (in [your] mind)" that it will be brought in, but your mind is wrong. Unless the developers completely change their minds about it. And when a group of people have worked together on something, and eventually decide to completely scrap it because the idea just isn't good enough, it is very rare for them to change their minds and say "yeah, actually it IS good enough". Especially if they have already told the whole world that the idea wasn't good enough, to bring it back suggests that they think their customers will accept second-rate stuff. Bunsen I saw the theory that Mimic will be recycled for Dawn of Fire on a thread:https://mysingingmonsters.fandom.com/wiki/Thread:67138

Wubbazt:

" "Mimic" is the first planned Quint-Element Monster, consisting of every Element other than Fire.  It was scrapped, though, most likely because there was no Island on which it was possible that such a Monster could be bred.  It might possibly come back in Dawn of Fire, though, where breeding Quint-Elements is entirely possible and canon.  The entire thing about Mimic could just be a rumour, however, as I haven't been able to find a verifiable source stating that there was a planned Quint-Element. Perhaps I missed something."

What Wubbazt had said about Mimic "coming back in Dawn of Fire", I thought she was right so I added my speculation about Mimic on the talk page of Dawn of Fire Quint Elements. You should have told Wubbazt that if anything is scrapped it will of course stay SCRAPPED. You never told her that. Floot Fly will also not return in Dawn of Fire (because the Monster Handlers possibly forgot the monster, it was first created and then scrapped like years ago before the original My Singing Monsters game was released). Also Bunsen what will be the name of the another fire element island if it doesn't have "Haven" in it's name? The developers probably want to avoid confusion so they might put something in it's name.